:中国话语权的评价科学研究是中国特色哲学社会科学研究的重要任务,是满足新时代中国制度、中国道路和中国理论、科技发展、管理与决策、评价理论和实践与社会协调发展的现实需要。文章梳理了国内外话语权与评价科学的研究现状,发现已有研究:缺乏专门论述中国话语权的评价科学的理论研究;缺乏综合系统的中国话语权的评价指标体系和方法研究;缺乏中国话语权的评价科学应用体系研究。在此基础上,文章论述了中国话语权的评价科学研究框架构建意义,并以顶层设计入手,提出了包含需求分析研究、理论研究、方法研究、评价与发布平台研究和应用体系研究五个要素的中国话语权的评价科学研究框架、逻辑关系图、指标体系构建流程图及评价与发布平台搭建模型图,并对各要素进行了分析。
Evaluation science of China's discourse power is an important task in the study of philosophy and social science with Chinese characteristics. It meets the realistic needs of China's system, road, theory, scientific and technological development, management and decision-making, evaluation theory and practice and coordinated development of society in the new era. This paper summarizes the research status of discourse power and evaluation science at home and abroad, and makes the following findings: Firstly, lack of theoretical research on evaluation science of discourse power in China; Secondly, lack of a comprehensive study on the evaluation index system and method of China's discourse power; Thirdly, lack of applied system research on the evaluation science of China's discourse power. Starting with the constructive significance and the top-level design, this paper puts forward the research framework of evaluation science, logical diagram, index system diagram and diagram of evaluation and publishing platform of China's discourse power, which includes five elements: requirement analysis, theory, method, evaluation and release platform and application system. At the same time, the elements are also analyzed.
[1] 尤莼洁.用好我们的话语权[J].新闻记者, 2011(3):20-21.
[2] 中华人民共和国科学技术部.关于开展清理“四唯”专项行动通知[EB/OL].[2018-12-31].http://www.most.gov.cn/tztg/201810/t20181023_142389.htm.
[3] 马维野.评价论[J].科学学研究,1996(3):5-8,80.
[4] 汤建民,邱均平.基于图书计量视角看我国评价研究近百年来的发展[J].情报杂志,2017,36(8):101-105.
[5] 沈壮海.学术话语体系建设的理与路[N].光明日报,2017-01-06(11).
[6] Harris Z S.Discourse Analysis[J].Language,1952,28(1):1-30.
[7] 庄琴芳.福柯后现代话语观与中国话语建构[J].外语学刊,2007(5):94-96 .
[8] 侯惠勤.意识形态的变革与话语权——再论马克思主义在当代的话语权[J].马克思主义研究,2006(1):45-51.
[9] Yakoba,Irina A.Discourse power of media space in the struggle for nomination[J].Tomsk State University Journal of Philology,2015(3):122-134.
[10] Xu Jie.The Exploration to Defense Mode and Guidance Strategy of Discourse Power for Network Community Groups[C].2016 6th ESE International Conference on Sports and Social Sciences.Pattaya,2016:196-202.
[11] Study on the Utilization of Group Discourse Power in Business Model in All-Media Era[C].The 2nd International Conference on Politics,Economics and Law.Weihai,2017(23):227-230.
[12] Lei Lei.Study on the Discourse Power of Government in Public Opinion[C].2nd International Conference on Contemporary Education,Social Sciences and Humanities (ICCESSH),2017:14-15.
[13] Fu H,Niu YB,Bao Q.Discourse power:the new explanation about the relationship between the administration power and the public[C].International Conference on Public Administration,2015:1151-1162.
[14] 王岩.新时代我国主流意识形态话语权的建构路径[J].马克思主义研究,2018(7):60-69,160.
[15] 阮建平.话语权与国际秩序的构建[J].现代国际关系,2003(5):31-37.
[16] 赵云泽,付冰清.当下中国网络话语权的社会阶层结构分析[J].国际新闻界,2010,32(5):63-70.
[17] 胡钦太.中国学术国际话语权的立体化建构[J].学术月刊,2013,45(3):5-13.
[18] Astbury B.Some reflections on Pawson's Science of Evaluation:A Realist Manifesto [J].Evaluation,2013,19(4):383-401.
[19] Leeuw F L,Donaldson S I.Theory in evaluation:Reducing confusion and encouraging debate[J].Evaluation,2015,21(4):467-480.
[20] Jamal F,Fletcher A,Shackleton N,et al.The three stages of building and testing mid-level theories in a realist RCT:a theoretical and methodological case-example[J].Trials,2015,16(1):466.
[21] Deane K L.Program theory-driven evaluation science in a youth development context[J].Evaluation & Program Planning,2014,45(45C):61-70.
[22] Patton M Q.Evaluation Science[J].American Journal of Evaluation,2018,39(2):183-200.
[23] 曹霞,孙成权,吴新年.国内外科技评估工作窥见[J].图书与情报,2005(6):91-94.
[24] 申丹娜.美国科技评估的国家决策及实践研究[J].自然辩证法研究,2017,33(4):51-56.
[25] Cariola M,Rolfo S.Evolution in the rationales of foresight in Europe[J].Futures,2004,(36):1063-1075.
[26] Tyler R W.Changing concepts of educational evaluation[J].International Journal of Educational Research,1986,10(1):1.
[27] Watkins R,Leigh D,Foshay R,et al.Kirkpatrick plus:Evaluation and continuous improvement with a community focus[J].Educational Technology Research & Development,1998,46(4):90-96.
[28] 李浩志.综合评价方法论研究[J].管理工程学报,1990(4):33-40.
[29] 文庭孝.科学评价理论体系的构建研究[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2008,14(3):63-69.
[30] 吴钢.我国教育评价学研究的回顾与展望[J].教育测量与评价,2010(3):19-22.
[31] 蒋银华.司法评价学的思维转向[J].国家检察官学院学报,2015,23(2):3-11,171.
[32] 汤建民,邱均平.评价科学在中国的发展概观和推进策略[J].科学学研究,2017,35(12):1813-1820,1831.
[33] 汤建民.建构和发展我国的评价科学[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2019,40(1):227-233.
[34] 叶继元.人文社会科学评价体系探讨[J].南京大学学报(哲学•人文科学•社会科学版),2010,47(1):97-110,160.
[35] 叶继元.学术“全评价”分析框架与创新质量评价的难点及其对策[J].河南大学学报(社会科学版),2016,56(5):151-156.
[36] 姜春林.学术评价学的学科体系及创建策略[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2018,39(2):225-232.
[37] 马海群.评价学的开创与奠基之作——评《评价学:理论、方法、实践》[J].图书情报知识,2011(4):122-126.
[38] 叶继元,袁曦临.中国学术评价的反思与展望[J].中国社会科学评价,2015(1):65-77,129.